You can watch the first episode here.
I wonder why they say it’s going to be hilarious. It’s not so far. But I also found the Behind the Scenes video and it’s funnier.
I liked their Mrs. Bennet though. Yes, she’s out of character, but at least I like her and can sympathise with her. She’s also the only character that made me laugh (once!).
I disliked the scenes with Amanda knocking on the door to her apartment. They’re so designed on sucking our sympathy for the poor Amanda locked in the Regency world by the naughty Lizzy! Of course we’d hate her if the situation was opposite and it were Lizzy begging to be let in, while Amanda kept her out.
It makes no sense either. Lizzy wouldn’t behave like that, not to mention that she’d return if she heard that Jane had troubles. Also, there’s no reason for Lizzy to keep Amanda locked in. She might still remain in the modern world if Amanda returned, and Lizzy isn’t a person to freely dispose of the life of others for her own amusement. Come on! Last time I behaved like that I was 10. Their Lizzy proves to be sillier than Lydia.
They said that Amanda would change the events, but otherwise they’d be faithful to the book and its characters. They failed on both accounts. Some events – Bingley’s meeting the girls before the Meryton Assembly or the Netherfield party’s presence in Hertfordshire on the preceding Sunday are the producers’ changes and have nothing to do with either Amanda’s presence or Austen’s book. The characters are out of character, and it only shows that Andrews didn’t read the book carefully enough. If you write fanfiction, do it intelligently.
I’m afraid that I don’t like Amanda. She’s not a girl I’d befriend in RL. Even today there are women who have more subtlety, are intelligent and eloquent. She lacks it all. Let’s face it: How silly one must be to identify with Amanda? And why on earth did she run to Netherfield? She read the book, so she knows Jane’s going to be fine.
As my friend noticed, Amanda seems pretty dumb like for such an Austen lover. She reads the novel daily, and yet she hasn’t learnt that one doesn’t address Miss Bingley ‘Caroline’ or her brother ‘Charles’.
I might like a parody of P&P, if, say, Rowan Atkinson played Mr. Darcy, but Lost in Austen is a poor melodrama.
My favourite lines from other blogs and reviews:
All we know of Elizabeth is that she is in modern Hammersmith and doesn’t seem keen to come back. I half expect she will eventually turn up 3 months pregnant and high on drugs.
Very Lost in Austen by Pete
It is a truth universally acknowledged that ITV commissioning editors are absolutely desperate to get a big ratings hit, so they must have been as giddy as a Regency spinster approaching 30 when they first saw Lost in Austen galloping over the horizon.
Last Night’s TV: Lost In Austen, ITV1 by Thomas Sutcliffe
What was utterly unconvincing was Amanda hurling her last cigarette away after just two puffs when she’s stuck in the 18th century and unlikely to get her paws on another packet for another 100 years or so.
Totally Lost in Austen by Lucy Rouse
Modern-day female gets transported back in time to become the heroine of a Jane Austen novel? Isn’t that what we used to call “an Andrew Davies adaptation”?
A comment to First Night: Lost in Austen by MickGJ
Posted by Sylwia